|
|
|
MAY'S JOURNALJuly 16th, 2008
Differences
POSTED AT 07:02 AM in My Life and what's left of it...
I had a field day at Mylot today. You see, I responded to a certain discussion there yesterday. My reply (which was the 22nd response in the thread) was a very simple and truthful reply. It got me the "Best Response" award however and I was rather surprised. I knew I wrote clearly and direct to the point but I was against the odds. I mean the question was about a guy who caught his girlfriend cheating on him and slapped her; was it justifiable to hurt the woman or not?
Almost all answers were of course it was not justifiable. Nobody deserves the right to hurt someone else and I agree with them. My reply however is telling everybody that what the guy did has a reason and it made one Mylot member irritated, she accused me of being an advocate of violence. Me? A battered wife? I condone violence? Gee! That's rather funny, but well, it's her opinion anyway. I've pasted the discussion below. Feel free to comment will you?
JUSTIFIABLE OR NOT?
|
|
|
Here's the scenario: A guy and his girlfriend attended a party at friend's house. A few
hours into the party, the girlfriend went a-missing. The boyfriend
searched frantically for her and finally found her in the backyard
under one of the trees there. But here's the big surprise: the
girlfriend was NOT alone! In fact, the boyfriend found her in a most
compromising situation: she was liplocked with another guy! The
boyfriend, very much hurt by what he saw, walked up to the kissing
couple and without a word, slapped the girlfriend. They have broken up
since then. Now my question is, was the guys reaction and
consequent action justifiable or not? Was his reason for hitting the
girl valid? Personally, I think what he did was a natural human
reaction. After all, he's only human. But I could be wrong. His
girlfriend was also human, right? A human who is prone to make
mistakes. So what do you think? Please share your two cents'.
|
|
|
22. maple_kisses (354)  |
16 hours ago |
|
Hmmm, it's like a movie scene. Well, let me quote a sentence or two from a book that I recently finished, it goes like this: "When Jonah was angry at God for killing the little gourd plant that
gave him shade in the desert, God told Him he had no right to be angry
by saying - You didn't raise it and love it as I did" This
means you can't pass judgment on what another person feel like, no one
can know what love and caring feel like to to someone else and what
lengths they will go for that love. I guess, the guy just
acted on the kind of love that he felt for the girl. It was violent and
it seemed wrong. Yet, it was a normal reaction to an action done. It's
like what Newton teaches us, something like, in every action there's
always an opposite and equal reaction. It was painful for the guy, the
normal and equal reaction would be to inflict pain. I'm a
woman, but I say, I feel for the guy rather than the gal. Emotional
pain is always more difficult to handle and to cure than the physical.
One thing more, the gal might have destroyed the guy's faith in love
and it'll scar him for the rest of his life. The gal, well, she
betrayed a guy once, she's more likely to do it again.. Oh well, this
is life.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
crazyoverpurple (521) |
15 hours ago |
|
Very
well said! As one saying goes, "Time heals all wounds". But I guess in
this situation that applies to the physical pain the girl felt when the
guy slapped her. As for the emotional scar that the guy endured and may
still be enduring, it will definitely take a while (if at all possible)
before he gets over it. Thanks for responding!
|
|
|
|
maple_kisses (354) |
15 hours ago |
|
Oh,
you're welcome... Seen the situation with a friend before, my friend
cheated on her boyfriend and he hurt her in return. I just saw the
situation clearly... Thanks for the "Best Response".
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ciniful (1104) |
9 hours ago |
|
And
people like this, who continue to condone violence, are the reason
we'll never stop it. You see it as 'just a slap' because he was angry.
How is that any different than the man who abuses his wife, because he
was angry? It's a reaction to his feelings, so that makes it alright? It's absolutely heartbreaking to see people continue to push violence
by condoning it. People like the both of you, by making excuses for it,
are partially to to blame for the next woman who earns herself black
eyes when her husband has a bad day. You allow and encourage the
behavior by defending it, even in the smallest of instances. Whether he was hurt or not is not an excuse to assault someone. People
get hurt all the time, no one is exempt. Should we all go and hit the
people who make us angry? Yep, that'll solve everything. Bottom line. The girl cheated on him, the guy assaulted the girl. Why
is his action excused while hers isn't? Says a lot about your thinking,
doesn't it?
|
|
|
|
maple_kisses (354) |
1 second ago |
|
Hi
there, it saddens me to know that you are somewhat irritated with my
response. You should know however that everybody's entitled to his/her
own opinion. I respect what you believe, the least you can do is
respect mine.
I am not an advocate of violence. Maybe you don't
know what it is to live in violence but I was a battered wife 5 years
ago, I had it all, punches, slaps and was even thrown at the door by my
ex-husband. He was violent to the T and he never have the right to do
such crime to me because he was never there when my Mom and Dad
nurtured me from conception to my 21st year in earth. No, you had it
wrong when you accused me of advocating violence, that is such a
laughable accusation.
However, we live in a world of reasons and
varieties. What might be reasonable to one isn't reasonable to someone
else. My drunk husband might find it reasonable to hurt me because he
wants to, I found no reason at all except that he's violent and a gay
for hurting a woman. Nope, we don't know every reason in every person's
mind but you have no right anyway to judge a person's action.
Sigh, this is just a proof that we can't please everybody. What pleases
the owner of this discussion won't please other members... It's ok, I
understand, I respect your point of view and I admire you for taking a
stand. God bless...
|
|
|
|
Well, that's it. I'm still waiting for the gurl's reply and if she will, I'll post it here for you to read...
Subscribe to my Feed
|
|
|